Overcoming a suicide tragedy: Otto Reyna’s quest to help the Latino community start talking
Otto Reyna thinks people need to talk to one another more about the way they’re feeling.
A native of Guatemala, and Summit County resident for nearly 20 years, Otto admits that’s a big ask for people of his Latin culture.
“In my culture, the subject of mental health, and especially suicide, is taboo,” he said. “But poor mental health is happening so much more with the pandemic. We have to start talking about it more so people can get help. It’s not easy to go through this.”
Otto’s own mental health journey began with the August suicide of a tenant in an upstairs bedroom of the home Otto was renting in Frisco.
The grisly scene Otto discovered will be forever etched in his mind, and it started a cascade of haunting questions: What drove a nice, quiet, young man to such desperate measures? Could Otto have done anything to prevent it? Why did this happen under his roof? Why couldn’t Otto get this man to talk about his struggles?
While most of the answers to these questions will remain a mystery, the sad and tragic suicide set Otto on a mission to advocate for “sharing how we’re feeling to reduce the taboo around talk of mental health.”
He said he wants to encourage others to share what they’re going through in order to help prevent and overcome tragedies — especially people in the Latino community who are not culturally predisposed to open up, to seek help for mental health needs or to access talk therapy as a way to heal.
“In this pandemic, and in the Latino community, people are hurting,” Otto said. “They need to know that help is available.”
As a man of deep faith, Otto said he’s directed to unturned stones for a reason, often a hidden purpose.
“I didn’t choose to live this event,” he said. “I didn’t choose it, and yet, here I am. I’m alive. And I want to help. And I thank God every minute of every day for that.”
Making Summit County home
Otto grew up one of three children in Chiquimula, Guatemala. His father died of cancer when Otto was 3, requiring his single mother to raise the family on the earnings of their mom and pop grocery store. Otto was ambitious and resourceful, finding his way to the University de San Carlos de Guatemala, where he earned a degree in business administration. Even with a strong resume, jobs were scarce in Guatemala.
“It was very tough, and continues to be, in my country to find a good job,” he said.
In 2001, in pursuit of the American dream, he packed up and moved to Summit County, where he had family. When he first arrived, unable to speak English, he gratefully took a job at McDonald’s for $7 an hour. In a few months, he learned English well enough to become a shift manager. His next move was to the Outlets at Silverthorne, where he managed various retail stores.
In 2015, Otto took a job as a property site manager with Summit Resort Group, an opportunity he describes as a “blessing.”
“Such good people,” he said about his coworkers. “They are like family. They have always been there when I needed them.”
In the years that followed, he went back and forth to Guatemala, eventually meeting and marrying Leiby, the mother of his now 3-year-old child, Ethan. Both Leiby and Ethan still live in Guatemala.
In May, Otto was living alone in a home that was too large for one person. With Leiby and the baby visiting only occasionally, he decided to rent his upstairs room.
“I put an ad on Craigslist, and this nice, young man from Denver answered it,” he said. “He impressed me immediately with his manner of dress, his trusting and trusted nature. I gave him the key.”
Over the next two months, Otto tried to engage his tenant in conversation, invite him for meals, ask if he wanted to kayak. But the man was always too busy even though he worked only sporadically.
“He was just so close to himself,” Otto remembers. “He stayed in his room all the time.”
A loud noise awakened Otto from a deep sleep in the early hours of Aug. 16. There was momentary confusion, then silence, so sleep once again overtook him.
Four days later, at the urging of Leiby on the phone, Otto checked on his tenant.
“It was an unimaginable horror scene,” Otto said slowly, working hard to hold his composure. “There were so many emotions: deep sadness, terror, loss, anger, guilt. It was chaos in my mind. The scene, it was overwhelming.”
Police came, the coroner, detectives, an ambulance. Otto was questioned for more than six hours. He later found his tenant’s handwritten bucket list. No. 4 on that list was to “go kayaking.” No. 10 was to “pull the trigger.”
Learning the lessons of a tragedy
Otto has spent months trying to make sense of it all. He knows it will take much longer but has come to a new understanding of what life means.
Through Milena Quiros, Building Hope Summit County’s Spanish outreach coordinator, he was connected to a therapist. Through talk therapy and eye-movement desensitization and reprocessing, Otto has been able to reframe the event in a way that makes sense to his brain. He has been able to let go of the guilt and depression surrounding the man’s death.
“My perception of everything has changed,” he said. “As a property manager, I used to say, ‘This needs to be done right now!’ I don’t say it anymore. Everything will get done when it needs to. The tragedy has made me double think what’s important. We worry so much about things that don’t really matter.
“It has made me want to help others by being a better listener, a better father and husband, a better friend, a better man,” he said. “We don’t always see the really good things that happen to us. Like waking up in the morning with the gift of having another day.
“It made me humbler and kinder, because you don’t know what people are going through. You see their faces; they may look happy, but you never know what’s going on inside of them.”
Faith, ever present in Otto’s life, also had a presence in his house. His Bible was always nearby, and he left encouraging notes to himself on the counter. “I know my tenant felt peace there,” Otto said. That concept gives Otto peace as well.
“As a Christian, I feel this has made me know that I can handle anything,” he said. “I think God has given me the chance to get through this circumstance — not just to live through it, but to appreciate all the small and big things in my life and to not take anything for granted, including the people around me.
“I feel a humbleness, a shared love. And hopefully I can help others who are going through really tough times.
“I’ve come to learn that what you choose to take from trauma defines you as a person. You can become defeated by trauma, or you can help others through it. I choose to help, and it starts with open and honest sharing.”
✴ ✴ ✴
Editor’s note: Written by Suzanne Acker, a special projects writer for Building Hope Summit County. Read the stories and watch videos of other community members at BuildingHopeSummit.org/about/hope.
Photos by Byron Swezy @dragonfruitvideo
Video by @dragonfruitvideo
24-hour crisis help:
• For life-threatening emergencies, call 911
• Colorado Crisis Services: 844-493-8255 or text “talk” to 38255
• To talk to a peer with lived-experience call Building Hope’s Peer Support Line: 970-485-6271 Option 2.
• Mind Springs Health: 970-668-3478
• Colorado Crisis Line: ColoradoCrisisServices.org
• Safe2Tell: 877-542-7233, Safe2Tell.org or download the Safe2Tell app to make a report
• Building Hope Summit County: BuildingHopeSummit.org
• Summit Community Care Clinic: 970-668-4040